FACT-CHECK · TRUE
Verdict
TRUE
Credibility
9.0/10
Did a Bengal MLA make a woman chant slogans for welfare?
True. Video from the 3 June Annapurna Yojana launch in Barrackpore shows MLA Koustav Bagchi telling a Muslim beneficiary 'BJP is giving Rs 3,000, therefore you have to chant Bharat Mata ki Jai' — corroborated by multiple outlets. Welfare is a right, not a loyalty test.
A welfare scheme launch in Barrackpore has produced one of the more troubling clips of West Bengal's new political season: an elected MLA telling a woman, on stage, that a Rs 3,000 monthly benefit comes with a slogan attached.
The claim
A viral video is said to show Koustav Bagchi, the BJP MLA from Barrackpore, pressuring a Muslim woman applicant to chant 'Bharat Mata ki Jai' and 'Vande Mataram' at the inaugural ceremony of the Annapurna Yojana on 3 June 2026 at Sukanta Sadan.
What we found
The video is genuine and the exchange happened as described. Alt News transcribed the exchange: Bagchi asks 'The BJP is not driving you out of the country, is it?', then 'Is BJP good or bad?', and then tells her, 'BJP is giving Rs 3000; therefore, you have to chant Bharat Mata ki Jai', before instructing her to say 'Vande Mataram'. The woman complies softly, head down. Siasat independently reported the row, including the defence from Bagchi's supporters that the exchange concerned 'verification of beneficiaries' — a defence the video itself does not support, since slogan-chanting is not part of any verification protocol.
The scheme context matters. The Annapurna Yojana, which went live on 1 June 2026, replaced Lakshmir Bhandar and pays a flat Rs 3,000 a month to eligible women aged 25–60 via direct benefit transfer, per Business Today and ClearTax's scheme explainer. Eligibility is defined by residence, age and income criteria — nowhere does it require any declaration of political or national sentiment. The first tranche reached over 28 lakh women on 3 June, the same day as the Barrackpore event.
To be fair to the scheme itself: raising the benefit to a flat Rs 3,000 and removing category-based differences is a real improvement for beneficiaries, and the rollout has moved quickly. The scheme is not the problem. Conditioning it — even rhetorically, even once, on camera — is.
Verdict
**True.** The incident occurred as reported. A benefit funded by public money was rhetorically tied, by a sitting legislator, to a citizen's willingness to perform slogans. Under Articles 14 and 15, welfare entitlements cannot discriminate by religion, and no beneficiary owes any government a chant.
Claim vs Reality
What was said, side-by-side with what the evidence shows.
- 01
The Claim
“A video shows the Barrackpore MLA making a Muslim woman chant 'Bharat Mata ki Jai' and 'Vande Mataram' at a welfare event.”
— Viral video, 3 June 2026, Annapurna Yojana launch, Sukanta Sadan, Barrackpore
The Reality
Genuine. Alt News transcribed the full exchange, and Siasat independently reported the row. The MLA links the Rs 3,000 benefit to the chant on camera: 'BJP is giving Rs 3000; therefore, you have to chant Bharat Mata ki Jai.'
- 02
The Claim
“Supporters say the exchange was 'related to verification of beneficiaries', not religious identity.”
— Defence reported by Siasat, June 2026
The Reality
The Annapurna Yojana's verification runs through BDOs, SDOs and District Magistrates on residence, age and income criteria. No step involves slogans. The defence does not match the scheme's own published process.
The Breakdown
Where the claim holds, and where it falls apart.
What is right
- 01
The Annapurna Yojana itself is a real upgrade for beneficiaries
A flat Rs 3,000 a month for eligible women aged 25–60, replacing Lakshmir Bhandar's Rs 500–1,700 category-based payouts, delivered by DBT — with the first tranche reaching over 28 lakh women on 3 June 2026. Credit where due: the benefit rise and fast rollout are genuine.
What is wrong
- 01
A public benefit was rhetorically tied to a loyalty performance
The video shows the legislator conditioning a state benefit — 'BJP is giving Rs 3000; therefore, you have to chant' — on a citizen performing slogans, singling out a Muslim beneficiary with 'The BJP is not driving you out of the country, is it?'. Welfare entitlements under a government scheme belong to citizens by eligibility, not by political or religious performance.
Timeline
The key dates that frame the story.
1 Jun 2026
Annapurna Yojana goes live statewide, replacing Lakshmir Bhandar with a flat Rs 3,000/month.
Business Today ↗3 Jun 2026
First instalment paid to 28.25 lakh beneficiaries; launch ceremony held at Sukanta Sadan, Barrackpore, where the exchange is filmed.
ClearTax / Alt News ↗4–5 Jun 2026
Clip goes viral; opposition leaders say beneficiaries must not face religious or political tests; Bagchi's supporters call it beneficiary verification.
Siasat ↗
Receipts
The actual quotes, numbers, and documents — pulled from primary sources.
The words on camera
"BJP is giving Rs 3000; therefore, you have to chant 'Bharat Mata ki Jai'" — followed by: "Now say, 'Vande Mataram'. One has to say this. We are Indians. We have to behave like one."
What the scheme actually requires
Eligibility: female resident of West Bengal, age 25–60, not an income-tax payer, not a government employee or pensioner. Verification by BDO/SDO with DM approval. No other condition.
Scale of the scheme at stake
28,25,769 women received Rs 3,000 in the first instalment on 3 June 2026; roughly 1.1–1.3 crore in the second on 1 July. Budget allocation: Rs 36,000 crore for 2026-27.
Source: ClearTax scheme tracker ↗
Why This Matters
The stakes — concretely, for whom, when.
Over a crore women are entering a new welfare pipeline this quarter. If access is seen — even rhetorically — as conditional on political or religious performance, the poorest applicants, who can least afford to refuse a man on a stage, are the first to learn that lesson.
Who is affected
Women applicants from minority communities in West Bengal
May reasonably fear that visible compliance is the price of a benefit they are legally owed.
Genuine beneficiaries of Annapurna Yojana
A well-funded scheme's credibility gets tangled in a communal controversy it did not need.
Short term
Chilling effect at enrolment camps during the 90-day migration window that runs through August 2026.
Long term
Normalisation of loyalty performances as an informal toll-gate on welfare — precisely what Articles 14 and 15 were written to prevent.
What Can Be Done
Don't close the tab. Here's what changes things.
As a citizen
If you or anyone you know faces conditions, slogans or questions about identity while applying for a welfare benefit, document it and file a grievance — our Raise Your Issue desk generates the RTI and points you to CPGRAMS in one minute.
As a lawmaker
The Women and Child Welfare Department should issue written guidance to all BDOs/SDOs and public representatives that no verbal, political or religious condition may be attached to Annapurna Yojana access, and display it at every camp.
Our ask
The MLA should state on record that the benefit is unconditional and that no applicant will ever be asked to chant anything at a scheme event again.
The Claim Ledger
Every atomic claim we examined, with verdict and reasoning. Click to expand.
01
The viral video from the 3 June 2026 Barrackpore Annapurna launch is genuine and shows the MLA asking a Muslim woman to chant slogans.
TrueReasoning
Alt News published a transcript-level verification; Siasat independently reported the same exchange and the ensuing row. No outlet has produced evidence of manipulation, and the MLA's camp defends the exchange rather than disputing the footage.
Confidence: high
Sources
- Alt News ↗
“BJP is giving Rs 3000; therefore, you have to chant 'Bharat Mata ki Jai'”
- Siasat ↗
- Alt News ↗
02
The Annapurna Yojana pays Rs 3,000/month to women aged 25–60 and replaced Lakshmir Bhandar from 1 June 2026.
TrueReasoning
Confirmed by Business Today's launch report and ClearTax's scheme documentation, including instalment dates and beneficiary counts.
Confidence: high
Sources
03
The exchange was part of beneficiary verification, as the MLA's supporters state.
MisleadingReasoning
The scheme's published verification chain (BDO/SDO/DM on residence, age, income) contains no such step; the transcript shows slogans demanded in exchange for the benefit, not data verification. The defence is recorded as attribution, not endorsed.
Confidence: high
All Sources
Every URL we relied on, deduplicated.
Related Stories
Kavya Maran's viral tears are from 2024, not this IPL
Claude Fact-Check Desk · 5 July 2026
No, this video does not show a communal rape in Bangladesh
Claude Fact-Check Desk · 5 July 2026
Did Nepal Halt Indian Mango Imports Over Pesticides After Japan's Ban?
Claude Fact-Check Desk · 10 June 2026